What first caught my eye was this report from Fox Digital that made the Sylvia Gonzalez case seem non-partisan
On 18 March 2024, Fox News Digital released the following video consisting primarily of the words of one of the lawyers from the firm supporting Sylvia Gonzalez before the Supreme Court.
In the deep-blue part of San Antonio, a city councilwoman carries a petition for her constituents and gets arrested
The Texan reported in a 23 October 2023 article on the case of Castle Hills Councilwoman Sylvia Gonzalez and the way the mayor, police chief, and city manager worked to squash the petition that got her elected, get rid of her First Amendment rights, and jail her.
The story contained in the alarming allegations raised by former Castle Hills City Councilwoman Sylvia Gonzales is fit for a movie plot. Now, the 76-year-old grandmother’s tale will be reviewed by justices of the U.S. Supreme Court to determine whether she may sue several officials who she says violated her constitutional rights.
According to court documents, Gonzales was concerned about the direction of Castle Hills, her small municipality surrounded by the larger City of San Antonio, and not only decided to run for city council but also started a citizen-led petition calling for the removal of the city manager.
The filings describe how Gonzales faced hostilities from incumbents in the city government and their political allies, beginning with an attempt to oust her immediately after being sworn into office by claiming her oath of office was not properly administered by the county sheriff.
Gonzales secured a court order preventing them from removing her from office, but the battle raged on.
At a city council meeting after the citizen-led petition calling for the removal of the city manager was presented, Gonzales says she briefly stepped away from the council dais. When she returned, Mayor JR Trevino asked her where the petition was, and after looking she found it inside her binder lying on the dais.
Gonzales says she doesn’t know how the petition came to be placed in her binder.
Trevino then instructed Chief of Police John Siemens to conduct an investigation into the seemingly innocuous moment.
After a Castle Hills police officer did not find any wrongdoing in his investigation, Siemens hired a local attorney, Alex Wright, who also holds a police commission with Castle Hills to conduct another investigation.
After a month of investigating, Wright obtained an arrest warrant for Gonzales, charging her with tampering with a government record — a misdemeanor, for which she was booked into jail as opposed to receiving a citation.
The efforts against her continued to pile up, with a group of citizens described as being “politically aligned” with Trevino filing a lawsuit seeking her removal from office, citing “incompetency” as the basis for their petition.
After beating back the criminal charges and the multiple attempts to remove her from office, Gonzales says that her reputation was destroyed and she was forced to spend thousands in legal bills.
Joining forces with the Institute for Justice (IJ), Gonzales filed a federal lawsuit against Trevino, Wright, and Siemens, alleging they violated her First and 14th Amendment rights.
The IJ, which is a public interest law firm, defeated a motion to dismiss at the trial court level but failed at the U.S. 5th Circuit after a multi-judge panel ruled that binding case precedent favored the defendants.
(Read more at the conservative source, The Texan)
For bringing the petition her consituents signed, they jailed her
Likewise, the San Antonio Express News reported in a 16 Octover 2023 article on the case that once involved both Sylvia Gonzalez and then-Alderwoman Lesley Wenger on what seem now to be trumped-up charges of evidence tampering.
Four years ago, a bitter political dispute in the small suburban city of Castle Hills landed a city council member in jail. The resulting lawsuit now is headed to the U.S. Supreme Court.
The high court on Friday agreed to consider an appeal by the former alderwoman, Sylvia Gonzalez, who was arrested by Castle Hills police in July 2019 and charged with tampering with a public document.
She spent a day in the Bexar County Jail but the charge was dismissed by the Bexar County District Attorney’s Office. Gonzalez filed a lawsuit in 2020 accusing other officials of retaliation.
The Supreme Court will decide whether Castle Hills officials, particularly the mayor and high-ranking police, can claim government immunity against lawsuits. The affluent North Side community along Loop 410 has about 4,000 residents.
Gonzalez, now 76, has said she was embarrassed by the arrest. She was placed in an orange inmate uniform, forced to sit on a cold metal bench and had her booking photo released to the media. Her lawsuit sought about $70,000 in legal fees and compensation for stress, harm to her reputation and loss of future job opportunities.
The lawsuit alleged violation of her rights under the First and Fourteenth amendments of the U.S. Constitution. She is represented by the Institute for Justice, a national law firm based in Virginia that bills itself as a guardian of basic American rights.
Senior U.S. District Judge David A. Ezra ruled in her favor, saying the city could have issued a summons for the nonviolent misdemeanor but got an arrest warrant instead, “which ensured that she would spend time in jail rather than remaining free and appearing before a judge.”
A three-member panel of the U.S. Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals, in a 2-1 ruling, reversed the district court, determining Gonzalez failed to prove her arrest was retaliatory and upholding the defendants’ claim of immunity.
Lawyers for Gonzalez have said she was the first Hispanic councilwoman ever elected in Castle Hills and was responding to concerns from residents when she “championed a nonbinding, citizen-signed petition calling for the removal of the city manager.”
“This act of political speech and petition, protected by the core of the First Amendment, was met with a coordinated campaign of retaliation by Castle Hills officials,” the institute said in its release.
Anya Bidwell, an attorney with the institute, said the appeals court’s decision “sets an impossible standard for victims of retaliatory arrest and punishment to prove their cases.”
“We are taking this case to the Supreme Court to ensure that government officials are held accountable when they violate the Constitution and that we stop this censorship by retaliation,” Bidwell said.
Castle Hills Mayor JR Treviño, listed as a defendant, along with Police Chief John Siemens and police Detective Alex Wright, declined to discuss the case.
“We can’t comment on pending litigation,” said Treviño, who also is chief operating officer of Treco Enterprises and interim president and CEO of the San Antonio Hispanic Chamber of Commerce.
In a release, the Institute for Justice called Gonzalez a “Texas grandmother” and retiree who endured “harassment, false charges, and even imprisonment, all stemming from her efforts to hold Castle Hills city officials accountable for their actions.”
Also arrested the same day, July 18, 2019, was then-Alderwoman Lesley Wenger, 77 at the time. She was charged with tampering with evidence and fraudulent use or possession of identification information.
Gonzalez and Wenger both were part of a three-member council majority that criticized City Manager Ryan Rapelye. They were accused in arrest affidavits of engaging in a yearlong effort to get him fired or force him to quit.
According to one police affidavit, Wenger copied information from Rapelye’s personnel file, including his Social Security number, driver’s license number, date of birth and information about his daughter, then later tore up the yellow sheet on which she’d written it — what police considered evidence. But the DA’s office also dismissed the charges against her.
Gonzalez was accused of illegally taking possession of petitions titled “Fix Our Streets” that called for Rapelye’s removal during a May 2019 council meeting, after a citizen said she’d been misled to sign one of the petitions “under false pretenses.”
The arrests also followed a 3-2 council vote supported by Wenger and Gonzalez a few weeks earlier to restrict residents from speaking until the end of regular council meetings. A new state law took effect in September 2019 that negated that vote, allowing the public to speak on individual agenda items during meetings of governmental bodies.
(Read more at the San Antonio Express News)
It’s odd how nobody brings to the conversation that this is all between Democrats
With the ways that both the press and political figures like Joe Biden regularly demonize Republicans, it’s odd that not one Republican has been involved in this fiasco.
Likewise, on the other end of the conversation, since Republicans are always demonized by the press and political figures, it would seem that either:
- Democrats would jealously guard their reputations and not let them get stained by rapscallions like Senator Bob Menendez, Mayor JR Trevino, or Hunter Biden’s loving daddy
- Or they would at least defend the weak that got them elected.
However, neither of these seem to be the case.
So, why hasn’t the Texas Democrat Party come out and excoriated this mayor and his compartriots? Why hasn’t Joe Biden come out and taken a stand for the little person who stood for what was right? Why hasn’t Kamala Harris hashed up some word salad on how this woman stood in the breach?
Could it be that they see us all as pawns to shuffle around? Are they currently unsure of which ones they will sacrifice before the game ends?
…
You must be logged in to post a comment.